At Oxford Hills High School

Sutton was an outstanding athlete, competing in Football, Basketball and Baseball. He was a First Team All-Conference choice his junior and senior years, and was voted the Offensive MVP in his final season. The South Paris, ME, who captained both the basketball and baseball squads, was also named to the KVAC All-Academic Teams for each of the three sports. The wide receiver was also given All-State Honorable Mention status in his junior campaign.